When we bought our home, we thought it needed only cosmetic updates — maybe updated appliances and a fresh coat of paint.
So, we felt pretty good about tackling our first project as homeowners: replacing the floors in our main downstairs living space.
We consulted specialists at a home-improvement chain, got measurements and estimates, and chose our luxury vinyl-plank flooring.
Between supplies and labor, we were quoted just under $6,000 to replace all the flooring on our first floor, which included our living room, kitchen, dining area, coat closet, and half bath.
Once demolition began, however, we realized the project would take longer and cost more than we had expected.
Problems started to surface when the contractors began to remove our floors
First, subcontractors removed the carpet in our living room and the old hardwoods in our kitchen. The carpet pulled up pretty easily, revealing wet subflooring near both sets of French doors that opened to our backyard.
They said we’d need to rent a dehumidifier to remove the moisture from these floors before the new ones could be installed.
My husband rushed out to find one, which we left on for a few days while we (and our dog) tiptoed around exposed nails and staples on our bare plywood subfloor. Thankfully, we didn’t have kids at the time.
From there, we learned our French doors were leaking badly and needed to be replaced — and so did a different section of damaged subflooring that couldn’t be salvaged.
Pressed for time, we hired some nice but inexperienced contractors to make the repairs for about $4,000. (We paid for this mistake a year later when our doors needed to be fixed again.)
After several weeks of waiting and wearing socks around the house to avoid splinters, we were able to resume our project.
Not very long after, one of the subcontractors cracked the drywall in our kitchen while using a crowbar to loosen the planks, which had been nailed to our baseboards.
We felt as if we couldn’t catch a break.
The floors looked great once they were installed, but the issues kept coming
Lauren Salles Gumpert
This project wasn’t done once our vinyl-plank flooring was put down.
Because the vinyl was thinner and lower than our old floors, our toilet and drop-through outlet no longer sat flush with the ground.
We had to pay a plumber to install a new flange — a crucial piece that fits over the drainage pipe, prevents leaks, and anchors the toilet to the floor. For a while, we lived with an elevated outlet in the middle of the floor, which created a tripping hazard for our kids.
Also, the vinyl flooring keeps our downstairs much cooler than our carpeted upstairs, where our bedrooms are.
This is mostly fine in the summer, but it contributes to a big temperature discrepancy in the winter. I have to keep our house’s thermostat set on the lower side so the heat doesn’t overwhelm us upstairs, but this means our downstairs gets really cold.
After all of this, we’ve been hesitant to do more home-improvement projects
Lauren Salles Gumpert
This “cosmetic” update, which has now cost us well over $12,000, has scared us away from wanting to pursue other home renovations, such as updating our bathrooms or landscaping our yard.
In fact, I now don’t believe most home-renovation projects are worth the hassle unless they’re functionally necessary. They’re rarely as easy as promised, and there’s always a possibility you’ll uncover costly issues or cause more problems in the process.
A lot of the time, I wish we’d left our floors alone. And if I’m honest, my young kids would’ve preferred the soft carpet to the harder vinyl floors, which I now cover with rugs, anyway.
This story was originally published on October 7, 2024, and most recently updated on September 4, 2026.
