In my 30s, I was the only one of my three siblings who wasn’t married or starting a family. At holidays and birthdays, I smiled through it and lead into becoming the cool aunt to my nieces and nephew. On Mother’s Day, however, I began bracing myself.
Each year, my mom would give me a card that said something like “Happy Mother’s Day from the dog.” It was meant with nothing but love. She wasn’t trying to minimize what I didn’t have — she was trying to include me. Still, each card landed like a small, unexpected dagger.
A reminder of the life I thought I was supposed to be living, but wasn’t.
I always imagined I’d be a mom
My mom would gently explain that I was a huge influence on my nieces and nephews. That they looked up to me. That mothering my dogs counted, too. And in a real sense, she was right — I wasn’t ready to accept it. I loved my dogs deeply — they kept me grounded and accountable. I was present in my nieces’ and nephews’ lives in meaningful ways, with time and energy to play with them.
Courtesy of the author
But privately, something still felt unfinished. I had always imagined I’d be a mom — driving a carload of kids to and from sports practices. Instead, I was the kids’ biggest fan, attending every hockey game or soccer match I could. At that stage of life, it felt like I was standing on the outside of a world I wanted for myself. For years, I held two truths at once: gratitude for what I had, and grief for what I didn’t.
That tension softened slowly over time — through perspective and by watching the realities of parenthood up close rather than the polished version in my head. I now understand those Mother’s Day cards differently. I see my mom’s big heart for what it is and always has been — her way of saying: “You matter. You belong. Your life counts, too.”
I saw the benefits that came without having kids
When I once confided to a friend that my only regret in life was not having children, he said, “Yeah, but look at all you’ve done. You might not have been able to do those things if you’d had kids.” His comment shifted something. For the first time, I allowed myself to see that not having children came with benefits as well as loss.
My siblings are wonderful parents, and their kids are thriving. But even when everything is going well, parenting adult children carries a constant low-grade stress: worries about their happiness, careers, relationships, health, and the world they’re inheriting. There’s an ever-present sense of responsibility that never fully goes away.
I care deeply about my nieces’ and nephew’s happiness, but I don’t carry that same weight. Instead, I live with a different set of trade-offs. The consequences of my decisions fall on me alone. That freedom has allowed me to further my education and take risks I might not have taken putting kids first, like: leaving full-time jobs to finish a TV pilot, jumping into dock diving my lab, and chasing a new dream of owning a quarter horse rescue and competing in reining.
I can say yes to opportunities that would be impractical for someone juggling school calendars and tuition bills.
I’m the cool aunt
And I still get to show up for the kids I love. Being the cool aunt turns out to be its own form of parenting — from a distance, without daily responsibility but with real influence. My role is lighter, but it’s not insignificant. Recently, my niece decided to attend the same college where I earned a graduate degree. Before she left, she told me: “Yes, the aunt influence is real.” It was said casually, but it landed deeply. Proof that presence doesn’t require parenthood. That modeling a curious, creative, and independent life can be just as formative as enforcing rules or paying for that college degree.
There’s a peaceful relief in releasing the version of adulthood I once carried guilt for not achieving — that lingering expectation of a conventional family life.
I still think about the life I once wanted. But I no longer see it as the life I failed to have. It’s simply one path among many. And the one I’m on now — dogs, dreams, creative risks — feels intentional. I’ve kept those Mother’s Day cards because they remind me that I have the very best mom. Her words and belief in me have taken decades to fully embrace but now that I have, I know: there is more than one ways to nurture, more than one way to matter, and more than one way to build a full life.
