- The father of a woman who Hamas killed has defended an award-winning image of her.
- The Associated Press image showed Shani Louk half-naked and face down in the back of a Hamas pickup truck.
- This article contains an image that may cause distress.
The father of a woman who was killed during Hamas’ October 7 attacks on Israel has defended the decision to present a prestigious journalism award to a freelancer who photographed her dead body.
The Associated Press freelancer Ali Mahmud won the Reynolds Journalism Institute’s Team Picture Story of the Year for the image, which showed Shani Louk’s lifeless body splayed in the back of a pickup truck and surrounded by Hamas militants.
Louk, a German tattoo artist, had been attending an outdoor “Festival for Peace” party near Kibbutz Urim when Hamas fighters targeted the area in a terrorist attack.
AP Photo/Ali Mahmud
The decision to award the prize for Mahmud’s photo received fierce backlash on social media and from some Jewish commentators.
The official X, formerly Twitter, profile for the State of Israel appeared to react to the news of the award by sharing several images of Louk alive and smiling, writing: “This is how we want Shani Louk to be remembered.”
Israeli writer Hen Mazzig also took to X to hit out at the decision, saying that the image “dehumanizes” Louk.
“The biggest photojournalism competition in the world decided to trample on the family’s wishes in favor of giving a photo of Shani’s mutilated body a prestigious award,” he wrote.
“Photos showing violence and death can be newsworthy or important when they humanize the dead or galvanize the public. The ‘winning’ photo does neither; it only further dehumanizes Shani, retraumatizes her family and legitimizes Hamas’s actions under the guise of journalistic neutrality,” he added.
“This is one of the most important photos in the last 50 years”
But Louk’s father, Nissim Louk, told Israeli news outlet Ynet that he was glad the photo won the award.
“It’s good that the photo won the prize. This is one of the most important photos in the last 50 years. These are some of the photos that shape human memory,” he said.
Nissim added that the image of his daughter and those of Noa Argamani being taken hostage by Hamas militants on a motorcycle were images that “symbolize this era.”
“I think it’s a good thing to use it to inform the future. If I start crying, what will come of it? This is history. In 100 years, they will look and know what happened here,” he added. “I travel the world, and everyone knows who Shani is.”
Hamas’ October 7 attacks killed around 1,200 people and saw around 240 others were kidnaped and taken hostage in Gaza.
Israel responded to the attacks with relentless airstrikes and a ground invasion of the territory. More than 32,000 Palestinians have so far been killed, Al Jazeera reported.
