Every Single Lex Luthor Actor, Ranked From Worst to Best

Due to the nature of his time on screen — essentially a cameo as a brainwashed version of Lex, who was friends with Superman and the rest of the Justice League — Barinholtz’s version of the character is at the bottom of this ranking.

But we’d like to see Barinholtz take another crack at it. Please give us a sequel to “The Lego Batman Movie,” Warner Bros.!

This is the first on-screen depiction of Superman’s greatest foe, just 10 years after his comics debut — and before his background was revamped for the Silver Age of comics in 1960.

Therefore, Talbot’s version of Lex is just too different from the character we’ve come to know and love (to hate) over the last 65 years.

This serial is fun, though, for any fan of Superman who wants to be a completionist.

Welliver was in just one episode of “Titans” before the character was killed off, but he made an impression. However, his version of Lex can’t be any higher because we barely saw it.

Welliver’s performance, though, does have the inherent malice and manipulation skills needed to be a solid Lex. We just wish we’d seen more.

Far and away, the most controversial portrayal of Lex is Eisenberg’s version of him in the now-defunct DC Extended Universe.

The first issue? It takes him the entire movie to be bald. We just can’t abide by that.

Secondly, Eisenberg’s version of Lex is too motormouthed and manic to be intimidating. And his plan in “Batman v Superman” is too convoluted to be scary. Remember the jar of pee?

Eisenberg himself knows that he wasn’t the most popular version of the character. “I was so poorly received,” he told Dax Shepard on an episode of “Armchair Expert” in 2024. “I’ve never said this before and it’s kind of embarrassing to admit, but I genuinely think it actually hurt my career in a real way.”

Cudlitz popped up in the final two seasons of The CW show “Superman & Lois,” which followed Supes and Lois on their journey as parents to twin teenagers.

His version of Lex is more of a brawler than some others and, weirdly, not that smart, which is a problem since his intellect is usually what makes him a formidable foe.

In a funny bit of meta-casting, Cryer was tapped to play this bald baddie 31 years after playing Lex’s nephew Lenny in “Superman IV: The Quest for Peace.”

However, Cryer (best known for his comedic roles in “Two and a Half Men” and “Pretty in Pink”) just wasn’t quite intimidating enough to be a plausible threat to Supergirl and the rest of the heroes from the Arrowverse.

We’re lumping the three vocal performances across the “Harley Quinn” and “Kite Man” universes together, since they’re equally brilliant, but ultimately, Lex isn’t a big enough character in the “Quinn”-verse to rate higher.

This version of Lex brought the idea of Clark/Superman and Lex as romantic rivals to our TV screens, as both were in love with Lois Lane (Teri Hatcher), a plot that was also used in “Smallville.”

Shea was only a series regular for the first season of “Lois & Clark,” so we didn’t get to see much of the arc between Superman and Lex, but he was a suitably sinister Lex.

He was also quite believable as a snarky businessman, a key part of the character.

Spacey’s performance as Lex is another controversial one, as he was supposed to be a continuation of Gene Hackman’s version of the character (more on that next), but the two weren’t all that similar.

Spacey’s version of Lex has more barely suppressed rage than Hackman’s, and while he might be even hammier than his predecessor, we’d argue that he’s almost as compelling.

Two scenes of Spacey’s stand out to us. First, when Lex is demonstrating his evil plan to his team on the model town, and he slowly disappears into the darkness. It’s genuinely eerie stuff.

Second is when he’s captured Lois on his megayacht, and he’s begging her to say that Superman will “never let you get away with this!” … only to scream “WRONG” in her face.

Hackman, who played Lex across three movies, is still probably the best-known and beloved version of the character. He’s a perfect foil to Christopher Reeve’s Boy Scout-esque version of Superman — while Superman is selfless, Lex is only interested in the bottom line.

Our only knock is that Hackman’s performance gets campier and more outsized as the movies go on, capped off by the abysmal “Quest for Peace.”

But if we limit his performance to the first two films, Hackman belongs on the comic-movie-villain Mount Rushmore.

Yes, he might be new, but Hoult’s version of Lex is an all-time, No. 1 Hater of Superman, which is really what the character boils down to. He just hates Superman’s guts and everything he stands for.

Hoult is also perfectly calibrated to director James Gunn’s wild and wacky tone, so his over-the-top moments don’t stand out. And, while a bit silly, he manages to be quite menacing throughout and unafraid to get his hands dirty to take down the Man of Steel.

There’s a speech Lex makes in this movie that also explains why he hates Superman so much: He’s jealous of him. That might be a simple idea, but it’s not one we’ve seen depicted on screen many times.

One of two Lex Luthors who played their character for a decade, Brown’s vocal performance as Lex is a standout in an animated universe that’s filled with iconic performances (Kevin Conroy as Batman, Tim Daly as Superman, Mark Hamill as the Joker, Dana Delany as Lois — we could go on…).

Brown’s version of the character is never anything less than cool. He’s smart, he’s rich, he’s got an iconic lair surrounded by an aquarium of sharks, and we wouldn’t want to cross him. What more could you ask for from Lex Luthor?

Are you surprised? Rosenbaum had seven seasons (plus a series finale cameo) to build his characterization of Lex. He starts the show as one of Clark’s friends and ends it as his biggest enemy (and also the president of the United States, somehow).

We got to learn about Lex’s tortured relationship with his father, his insecurities about his intellect, and his insatiable curiosity.

It’s the most fully realized version of the character, and for that reason, Rosenbaum ranks No. 1.