Most NATO Armies Can’t Meet Ukrainian Standards: Ret. US Army General

A retired US Army general said it’s most of NATO, not Ukraine, that has to learn from the other about combat.

Ret. Lt. Gen. Ben Hodges was asked in a video interview with the Kyiv Post, published on Tuesday, about what Ukraine’s NATO allies could do to help Kyiv’s military reach Western standards.

But Hodges flipped the question on its head.

“Well, actually, it’s not about meeting Western standards. Most NATO armies could not meet Ukrainian standards, in terms of actual combat effectiveness,” said Hodges, who was the US Army’s commanding general in Europe from 2014 to 2017.

Hodges highlighted what he said was a gap in NATO capabilities, such as poor cohesion among fighting units from different member states.

“We still cannot communicate securely with British or German units,” Hodges said. “So I think the Ukrainians kind of look down their noses at us a little bit, you know, when they hear us go: ‘We’re going to come help train you.'”

“We should be begging them to help us learn how to do what they’re doing,” he continued.

NATO said in May that it has trained roughly 192,000 Ukrainian personnel so far. Some were sent to NATO sites to learn how to use Western equipment. At least a dozen brigades were also directly instructed outside Ukraine on tactics and maneuvers by European and American military trainers.

Some units have criticized parts of that training, saying there were gaps between what they were taught and the battlefield’s realities. The dominant use of cheap hobby drones as deadly weapons, for example, is a new development that’s changed the face of war.

In his interview, Hodges also cited Kyiv’s naval operations in the Black Sea as an example of what NATO forces could learn.

“They have shown the entire world that you can defeat a conventional navy, at least in an enclosed body of water like the Black Sea, without having to have capital ships of your own. Lots for us to learn there,” he said.

“That may not apply in the Atlantic Ocean, but certainly in the Baltic Sea, the Mediterranean, the Black Sea, these kinds of things. I hope we are paying attention,” Hodges added.

Romania and Bulgaria, he said, could benefit from building up fleets of uncrewed vessels the way Ukraine created and used its own to counter Russia’s Black Sea Fleet.

Hodges said he was also impressed by Ukraine’s integrated air and missile defense to give it a clear picture of all the incoming aerial threats it’s facing at any given time, such as fighter jets, missiles, or drones.

“The Ukrainians have developed that for themselves. I would want to be confident that we have a shared picture between them, Poland, Baltic countries, Germany, the US, Romania, for example, Turkey,” he said.

He said the right system would help prevent NATO states from using the wrong weapons to take down targets.

“You’re not going to waste Patriots on drones,” Hodges said.

In February, NATO inaugurated a department in Poland called the NATO-Ukraine Joint Analysis, Training, and Education Center. The alliance said the center would focus on gleaning lessons from the war in Ukraine to “better position NATO’s deterrence.”

Meanwhile, Hodges said that Ukraine does have to learn how to reshape its military as an institution. Much of the country’s forces were built on a Soviet organizational culture that Ukrainian troops frequently bemoan as a source of poor decision-making and unnecessary bureaucracy.

“That means that the government has got to earn the confidence of the people,” Hodges said. “That their sons or daughters will not get sent off to the war until they are properly trained, properly equipped, and put into a well-trained, ready unit.”