Trying on Denim Jackets From Old Navy, Banana Republic, Gap: REVIEW

If there’s one closet staple that’s stood the test of time, it’s the denim jacket. From oversize looks to slimmer silhouettes, it’s been a consistent symbol of effortless, cool fashion for years.

Now that spring is here, it’s the perfect time to invest in a new transitional piece, whether layered over floral dresses or paired with jeans for a full-denim ensemble.

I was well overdue for a new one, so I ordered and tested three different denim jackets from Gap Inc. retailers Gap, Old Navy, and Banana Republic.

I liked them all, but one stood out as the classic wardrobe staple I was looking for — and I’ve been wearing it on repeat.

First, I tried out a trendy style from Banana Republic

I was originally drawn to Banana Republic’s washed-cotton chore jacket for its oversize, slouchy fit, which aligns with the laid-back vibe of today’s trending fashion.

Plus, I thought the relaxed silhouette would make for easy layering.

The wore this option to brunch with a friend, so I styled the jacket with a lace mini dress and heeled boots for a feminine spring look.

Overall, I loved that this jacket offered lots of unique styling options.

However, I wish the store sold this one in petite sizes, as it was a bit too oversize on my 5’2″ frame. The Banana Republic website recommends ordering down a size or two for a more classic fit, and I definitely agree that this is the right move.

The fabric felt soft, comfortable, and breathable enough for spring weather, which made sense considering it was made with 100% cotton.

Does that warrant a nearly $200 price tag, though? I’m not so sure. Banana Republic has done an excellent job at positioning itself as an attainable luxury brand, but to me, that price seems a bit steep for a jean jacket.

Next, I wore a more affordable option from Old Navy

The oversized jean trucker jacket from Old Navy felt like a mix of a modern fit and the traditional denim look. It was structured yet roomy, with plenty of space for effortless styling.

I wore it for a day of errands, pairing it with white capris and comfortable wedges for an elevated but casual look.

I thought the jacket looked nice on me and fit comfortably, but it didn’t necessarily impress me. The fabric (a blend of 95% cotton and 5% recycled cotton) felt and looked a bit flimsy and wasn’t as structured as I’d expect from a classic denim jacket.

But honestly, for only $60, I thought it was a solid option.

Finally, I put on the Gap jacket for a day out

Although I liked the modern look of the Banana Republic jacket and the accessible price of the Old Navy one, the Gap denim jacket completely won me over.

The classic silhouette, wash, and fit reminded me of why the world fell in love with denim jackets in the first place — and why they’re still in style today.

I wore this option for a Saturday outing (lunch, shopping, and walking around town) and paired it with jeans and heeled boots. The outfit gave me an instant boost of confidence — there’s nothing quite like a casual yet cool outfit to put a strut in my step.

I especially loved the durable, structured fit that seemed like it would last for years. Although the material (95% cotton and 5% recycled cotton) felt a bit tougher than the other options, it was still comfortable and breathable enough for changing spring weather.

Plus, even though the fabric makeup was similar to that of the Old Navy jacket, it felt much more durable and high-quality. So, for a wardrobe essential like this, I think it’s worth the $100 investment.

I have been wearing it regularly since I ordered it, and I know I will continue to style it throughout every season.